| Author | Comment | Last activity | Moderation | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| stoft | "@viechdokter suggests that I'm proposing a 'gatekeeper' but that's too simplistic and I'm not. Sorry for any confusion from what I wrote. Sure, kee..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| stoft | "@Warren, yes, I do acknowledge your points and @viechdokter 's. I would differentiate by noting that I'm not suggesting to disable or remove the ex..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| david-days | "@viechdokter, my approach would be to apply the "filtering" on the search end of the system (but I am a software developer, so my approaches tend t..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| warren | "@stoft - great start. I guess implicit is that anyone could go down a checklist like this as part of reviewing. Obviously lots to discuss, and may ..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| liz | "Hi everyone! I wrote up a description of the upcoming OpenHour and put links to this note as well as to the mailing list discussions, wiki pages, a..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| stoft | "@Warren, good and glad to see this list. 1 - Foremost, there should be a set of categories (similar to the brief list in the 'blank' note for sugg..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| viechdokter | "I do agree that "someone" should try to organize content into categories, but I thought that's what the tags were for? As for the filtering of "go..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| david-days | "@stoft, I agree with what you are saying, and have a personal interest in helping to make that happen. Without a means of narrowing down PLab sear..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| warren | "@stoft - ah ok, good, then were on the same page there. I guess the question is then who can make such assessments how do we trust the assessment..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| stoft | "@liz, right. A simplistic example is the 'tree' of the web site with one section being 'research'. It's fine to see 'new posts' listed (just labele..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| liz | "ah @stoft, am i hearing correctly that this is also about navigation through "the tree" in your metaphor? @Gretchengehrke has been very articulate ..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| stoft | "@Warren, I don't see that anyone is suggesting credential based peer review for PLab but IMHO, that does not exclude filtering based on good scienc..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| stoft | "@david-days, right. So, I have a theory ... right place for theories, right? ... that having a diverse source of contributors means just as diverse..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| warren | "I found this section really interesting and reflective of some of the balance we're seeking here too: http://www.nature.com/news/peer-review-troub..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| david-days | "@stoft, I agree with all of your points regarding peer review (by whatever phrasing). You're also correct about the term "citizen scientist", in ..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| liz | "Great topics in here! I wanted to invite you all to the (not yet publicly announced) upcoming May 2, 8pm, OpenHour "hangout" on "Public Lab's resea..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| stoft | "Well, I'll chip in an alternative $0.02. I view formal / official peer review, the peer review 'scientific' concept, the peer review concept and en..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| david-days | ""Citizen scientist" is a phrase I picked up along the way (I think here, but I've also seen it around the web). I think it's a good description of..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| viechdokter | "Wow, "citizen scientist"! I have never thought about it that way. But you are right. I dived into PLab spectrometry by chance and found that it rea..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago | |||
| david-days | "I went through this for an autonomous navigation paper that I was trying to get published. Because the topic (navigation for robots in general) f..." | Read more » | over 8 years ago |